Probably. My approach was to use dialectic to guide my rejoinder to the rhetorical potshot. Confronting the informal logical fallacy used would then make the claim irrational.
False dichotomy, unless there is some absolute, monetary and ecumenical metric that exposes the faithful as actually being mired in materialism that I'm not aware of. I think it's safe to say that Timmy has demonstrated on countless occasions that this is not the case.
McPherson looks like a great pickup. Pineiro will be a hard act to follow but McPherson's deep kickoffs and the way the ball comes off his foot on field goals and PATs is a good sign. Plus, the natural draw on his kicks is aesthetically pleasing.