So let’s parse this out. You don’t like him based on a lot of secondhand accounts from 2005-08 when he was an assistant, correct? Going deeper:
Recruiting as HC - Doesn’t meet UF standard.
Offensive philosophy - I like it but you don’t, I’m guessing.
Offensive game management - I’m guessing outside some boneheaded calls, you like it too.
Defensive philosophy - Think we both agree that it works for the MSUs of the world but needs to get better here.
Defensive game management - Same as above.
STs - meh? Good talent at kicker/punter but return scheme’s leave a lot to be desired.
S&C - Probably where you add most to the conversation and it seems like you think Savage is doing a very good job considering his restraints, correct?
Media presentation - Better than most thought.
If I’m wrong on your views, let me know but I think the first point about secondhand observations overpowers how you feel about him in performance. Differently stated - if he was someone else that you didn’t have that secondhand interaction with, you’d probably present a much more positive view publicly.
