Johnson filed a complaint with UF’s Office of Internal Audit that contains information from public records that were provided to him. The documents include criticism of Keith’s legal abilities and management style and the hiring of a consultant to work with her to address the criticism.
Ironically, the UF audit office started a case on Keith in response to a November 2015 anonymous letter to the UF Board of Trustees critical of Keith that was signed “Concerned employees of the General Counsel” and to a February 2016 anonymous complaint to UF’s Ethics and Compliance Hotline that also was critical of Keith.
However, top UF leaders, including President Kent Fuchs, Chief of Staff Win Phillips and Chief Operating Officer Charles Lane, opted instead to hire consultant Herschel Kahn, a “colleague” of Trustee David Thomas, to coach Keith.
Lane, in an email with the subject heading “Anonymous Letter and Anonymous Hotline Call,” asked UF’s chief auditor, Brian Mikell, to “take appropriate steps to close out this case” based on the hiring of Kahn.
Keith had a role in writing Kahn’s retainer to meet with her and help develop a survey of her staff. Most of the responses were negative toward Keith.