We would've been blown out by Alabama in 2012. Total smoke and mirrors, the entire season. Also, don't forget, even with the TD, we still needed a 2-point conversion, and that just got us to a tie. Even after, when we could've leaned on the defense(his area) to get the ball back, we instead accrued two 15-yard penalties and gave up a 22 yard run to finish the game. I have little doubt that they would've move the ball on us if they'd needed to in order to at least kick a FG. That afternoon, along with the rest of WM's tenure, was solely the product of a stubborn imbecile who isn't cut out to run a hot dog stand but was inexplicably given the keys to the best job in cfb at the time. Reed's one play has practically no bearing, imo.
But I do agree with you that he was outstanding and if not for injuries may have been our best TE in the NFL. I also give him a lot of credit for learning his role in college while also subbing in at times as QB, even if he didn't know the plays, and dealing with 3 different offensive systems. Great team player., represented us well and I wish him the best in his next venture.