Single-season greatness: 2007 Tebow, 2010 Newton or 2012 Manziel?

[78]

Is it worthy of a ban to pose this question in the first place?

I'm beyond that. Have you even looked at my dislikes lately?

 

[GatorJB]

Tebow scored more total touchdowns in a single season than both of them. Tebow scored 55 in 13 games. Took Newton 14 games to get 51, but Tebow was still able to get more rushing and passing TD's. Manziel's best was 47.

TD's are more important than yards so I give Tebow the edge. Yes Newton won championships that year, but that's a team accomplishment. Tebow played well enough to win championships. Unfortunately his defense that year stunk.

 

[InstiGATOR1]

Manziel is easily the worst season of the ones you picked. He was not that efficient a QB which is why the aTm coaches coached him up the next season to run with the ball less and be a better QB.

I guess Tebow's season comes next. He was a very efficient passer, but not quite the runner.

Newton clearly to me had the best of the seasons mentioned. He really carried that AU team offensively.

 

[Gator4Life]

F turning off bias. Tebow is my pick because he was the best leader, stats be damned.

Tebow was a Mack truck of a player I'd take another one like him any day over the other two hands down

 

[Blacklabgator]

Manziel playing stoned is pretty impressive.

 

[TheDouglas78]

Bradford's numbers in 2008.

I forgot how video game statistics his passing numbers were that year... big 12 defenses are garbage.

 

[LeeForThree]

Not even a debate imo...Tebow had the best single season!!!

 

[MADGator]

This is easy! Manziel doesn't have a statue, so he's out, and I'm an unabashed homer so yeah, Timmy.