I am for McElwain because that is what is best for UF's football program.
I want Butters fired quickly because it obvious, just as obvious as it was by EARLY in 2012 with Mushchump (despite the record at the time), that Butters doesnt have what it takes to be a championship coach. He didnt even have what it takes to be a championship coach in the Little Leagues. He was, at best, a four loss coach who had several embarrassing and unexplanable defeats (AFA at Colorado State, Tinerc and Arky here) even in his best years.
No coach who cant recruit and cant score points will ever be a champiinship coach, no matter how much you like his Aw Shucks personality.
What might change my mind:
if we start TRYING to score points, not necessarily succeeding bc frankly that wont happen w our current roster, just trying rather playing Saban/Woody Hayes ball; AND
we immediately (because the effects arent felt for 3-4 years) starting recruiting like the elite team in the SEC. That means Bammer, OSU Clown Town level, not 6-7th in the SEC /9th-15th in the nation (which requires RAPID major upgrades to the staff).
I dont see this happening of course. Donkeys dont change their stripes.