LDR has yet to play well in a scrimmage from what I understand. He keeps that up Appleby will overtake him. Especially since he has played well in the scrimmages.
Sad to say but I don't think the QB situation gets solved until we are well into the season. I think the 2 guys are probably pretty close.....yet neither will end up being very good. If the offensive line and running game emerges I'll be happier than a pig in sh!t because serviceable is likely what we end up with at QB this season. I could be wrong but letting any QB on this roster chuck it around 40 times a game looks like a recipe for disaster to me.
Crete, I think this is an accurate post, but in the interest of full disclosure you should point out that you wouldn't want 40 passes a game if you had Joe Namath and Jerry Rice on the team.Sad to say but I don't think the QB situation gets solved until we are well into the season. I think the 2 guys are probably pretty close.....yet neither will end up being very good. If the offensive line and running game emerges I'll be happier than a pig in sh!t because serviceable is likely what we end up with at QB this season. I could be wrong but letting any QB on this roster chuck it around 40 times a game looks like a recipe for disaster to me.
Crete, I think this is an accurate post, but in the interest of full disclosure you should point out that you wouldn't want 40 passes a game if you had Joe Namath and Jerry Rice on the team.
Not true. If I felt confident in a high percentage PROVEN QB with an experienced offensive line that would keep him off a stretcher I wouldn't care if we went a little pass happy.....As it is we have a three time transfer who's arm resembles the instant vermicelli that I'm having for dinner and a guy who couldn't keep a starting job at Purdue....Most QB's don't magically get better. They either got it or they don't.Crete, I think this is an accurate post, but in the interest of full disclosure you should point out that you wouldn't want 40 passes a game if you had Joe Namath and Jerry Rice on the team.
We already have plenty of WR's from the 2016 class....What we need now is a guy who can get it to them....BTW would it hurt the staff to make a LBer, DT, or OT a top priority for next year.I'm surprised Crete didn't melt like the Wicked Witch (*) when he saw that 3 of next year's reported top 5 targeted recruits are wide receivers. (I would assume they don't get rated that high if they're primarily used as blockers.)
* Not suggesting that Crete is the Wicked Witch. But he convincingly demonstrates a Woody Hayes attitude about offense most of the time.
.BTW would it hurt the staff to make a LBer, DT, or OT a top priority for next year.
I remember when I thought CW would make JD a star. Then I remember thinking BP would make JD good. Then I prayed KR would make JD a decent game manager.......Then last year I remember wishing DN could teach TH how to play on stilts. Wish in one hand and pray supplement boy has a change of heart in the other.Of course I disagree. I think we will have a decent game manager this year that wont visit the supliment store.
Most qbs don't ...get better. Ummmm, qb for your hogs got consistently better so that by last year he was decent.Not true. If I felt confident in a high percentage PROVEN QB with an experienced offensive line that would keep him off a stretcher I wouldn't care if we went a little pass happy.....As it is we have a three time transfer who's arm resembles the instant vermicelli that I'm having for dinner and a guy who couldn't keep a starting job at Purdue....Most QB's don't magically get better. They either got it or they don't.
I remember when I thought CW would make JD a star. Then I remember thinking BP would make JD good. Then I prayed KR would make JD a decent game manager.......Then last year I remember wishing DN could teach TH how to play on stilts. Wish in one hand and pray supplement boy has a change of heart in the other.
Sure they can refine their skills and use experience to help them. But if they suck really bad then they usually stay in that suckage. If they show up off the bat, DW, CL, RG, TT, and WG, then you know you got something to work with. If you're referencing Brandon Allen, he started as a freshmen which may not mean much at a talent depleted program like Arky but it's obvious he had true talent.Most qbs don't ...get better. Ummmm, qb for your hogs got consistently better so that by last year he was decent.
I remember when I thought CW would make JD a star. Then I remember thinking BP would make JD good. Then I prayed KR would make JD a decent game manager.......Then last year I remember wishing DN could teach TH how to play on stilts.
"True talent" ! Gimme a break. He looked like crap up to his senior year.Sure they can refine their skills and use experience to help them. But if they suck really bad then they usually stay in that suckage. If they show up off the bat, DW, CL, RG, TT, and WG, then you know you got something to work with. If you're referencing Brandon Allen, he started as a freshmen which may not mean much at a talent depleted program like Arky but it's obvious he had true talent.
I had to look up his career numbers to refresh my memory. I was wrong about him starting as a freshmen. He had a decent junior season and a good senior year. There is NOBODY on this planet that would have had decent numbers on that train wreck,2012- 2013, that John L Smith left there..."True talent" ! Gimme a break. He looked like crap up to his senior year.
Coudda, woudda, shoudda....I had to look up his career numbers to refresh my memory. I was wrong about him starting as a freshmen. He had a decent junior season and a good senior year. There is NOBODY on this planet that would have had decent numbers on that train wreck,2012- 2013, that John L Smith left there...