[QUOTE='78;n119933]You guys crack me up. No. 1, I don't give a crap how well his defenses stacked up at Auburn or Texas, they were STAUNCH here absent a decent offense to take the heat off. No. 2, KC, good God, have you not noticed how critical of Muschamp I've been over the past year, etc.? I'm speaking to what I believe is the truth. [/QUOTE]
Agree with you. 2 years ago the D was phenomenal - excluding the bowl game. This year the D has been better than average. Our problem is not defense.
The D was pretty good at his year at LSU as I recall.
As to TX, when he left they sucked but prior years I think they were pretty good. TX ran a wide open offense so its not likely you are going to get a shut down defense.
Two out of three years at TX he was their they only lost 1 game. 2009 they beat OK by a similar margin as FL did in the national championship. 2006/2007 those were pretty respectable Auburn teams - one year only 2 losses. I don't recall any specifics about their defense.
So either Muschamp was a good defensive coordinator or lucky enough to keep getting hired by successful programs that made him look good.
The D wasn't the problem here. The problem for Muschamp was the offense, and I don't think Muschamp has really figured out in his head an overall philosophy. He came in wanting a ball control grind it out offense, but didn't have the personnel to do it. Then he flopped OC's a couple of times (or they left). Then he went with Roper and decided to go more wide open, but didn't have the personnel to do that, or enough time for the offense to figure it out.. For much of the time his chips were cashed in on a QB who just couldn't play on Saturdays.
Compare that to Stoops when he went to OK. In spite of being a D-Coor, he decided day one he wanted a wide open offense,and has always stuck with it, for better or for worse. Or Saban, who has generally went with a conservative offense from day one. Each has their own core philosophy that they stuck with and recruited to, so that when OC's inevitably leave it wasn't the end of the world and it wasn't like starting from scratch again.