Like I said before. I love CL and the NC he brought us. He threw a frozen rope, was a model Gator (never got in trouble), kept his nose in the play book, and was great on the field.
(1) However, let us be honest. If we didn't have Tebow to come in and get that 4th and short against 11essee we would have los that game and no NC.
(2) He was a good QB, but not elite.
(3) Yes I know he owns the most passing yards in a career at Florida and second in TD passes to Wuerffel, but he started all 4 years of his career (well 9 games of his freshman season anyway)...
(1) I was as pissed about Leak going down early as anyone. And I think you're right, in that Tebow kept the dream alive with that play. Unfortunately for Leak, that
ONE PLAY sticks in the mind of every Gator, and like you, they diminish how great Leak was because of it. Every time this argument comes up it always comes back to that ONE PLAY.
- No one remembers all the great plays
HE DID make in the Tenn game and hardly
anyone ever remembers he was the MVP of the National Championship game.
- Every QB who has
ever won a NC has had another player bail him out to save a game or season after they made a boneheaded play. Therefore, Leak's boneheaded play doesn't diminish all the greatness he brought to the team.
(2) He survived the Zook years and the Meyer transition. He won us a national championship and set records along the way. I love Kerwin Bell and will forever remember screaming my head off at the infamous 86 Auburn game. But in terms of being "elite", how can you one say Bell was elite and ignore Leak who
surpassed him in everything, including winning a national championship??? Bell was great. I don't even have a problem with saying he was elite. But there's no way to argue Bell was elite and ignore that Leak accomplished far more than him.
Leak = Elite college QB. Period.
(3) Wuerffel played as a freshman too. AND he was coached by The Ole's Ball coach himself and spent his entire college career in the fun-and-gun offense. Meanwhile Leak shares his years between Zook and Meyer. Zook was not running nearly as potent of an offense as SOS and Meyer ran a system that was ill equipped for Leak but at least was a good enough coach to recognize the talent he had to adjusted his system somewhat to fit Leak's talents.
Leak is 1st and 2nd in career passing and in touchdown passes in UF history. That EASILY puts him in the Top 5 all time QB's at UF...He is only 1 of 3 QB's to
ever win a national championship. That alone puts him in the Top 3 QB's in UF history.