As bad as Billy has been, we should have beat Utah, Mizz, and Arky. We could have and probably should have beat FSU. With a reasonably disciplined team all of those games are wins this year. Mullen absolutely left a talent gap for Billy, but it’s hard to think a decent coach wouldn’t have gone 9-3 this year.
Despite our problems, we could have had a very solid year with just a few tweaks:
-Solid OC
-Top 50 defense (we didn’t need to be world beaters on defense this year)
-Basic tackling
-Special teams that isn’t a disaster
-Decent o-line play
-Disciplined players
None of those things are too much to ask with this roster and all of them are absolutely within reach with a mid-tier coach. We don’t even have a mid tier coach..
I just don’t see how Billy improves next year with an absolutely brutal schedule. It’s hard to envision a solid year next year. I really want Billy to work out. I just don’t see a path to success. Maybe, and it’s a big maybe he can turn the corner with Major staff changes. I just don’t see it.