I for one do not think you are hard headed in all regards. Some regards, yes, but not all. I actually subscribe to your last paragraph quite a bit and have one rather substantial account that is based on that thought. I call it my fixed income portfolio, without any fixed income. They are basically common stocks, with dividends between 3 % and 8% and for the most part are not very volatile in normal times. Now they have been a little more volatile in the past few years and I concede that the upside may not be that great, but I also believe the downside is limited. Now I am very selective about my entry points, which a lot of people are not using this strategy b/c they just look at the dividend, but very high dividends could be very huge red flags. Just a few names that allow me to sleep at night and don;t offer huge wins or losses are T, VZ, PM, MO, and many electric Utilities. My biggest losers come from the pipelines group but they have stabilized a bit. But if purchased correctly, some big winners have been had in names like CVS, BX, Even IBM at a time, ABBV, Etc. These offered juicy total returns relative to some of the stodgy utilities, but it was the stable dividend that drove me to them initially.