To be honest, I think we are way ahead of schedule. Mac was left with what, two scholarship OLine with any experience? When he took over, how many of us thought this was a three year project just to be competitive. We've now won the East twice in two years. Is that good? Better than not, but not a huge obstacle. Has Mac done the best with what he's been dealt? Well no. Roster management has been reactive is his first two years, instead of proactive. He scrambled to put together a staff, and he did find a couple decent guys from the lower ranks. Dixon and Skipper are actually decent recruiters and appear to be good coaches. Shannon has been a good coach, but has not pulled in big names yet. However, he has brought in some good guys who were underrated. Rumph and Gray have been top notch replacements from the "original" staff. Nuss and Nord need to be gone. Summers is a good coach, but needs help recruiting. Our OLine is better. Our D looks better for next year than anyone really thought. There are positives.
Is he going to get us championships? I hope so, but it doesn't look good right now. There are only so many top notch coaches: Saban, Meyer, and Harbaugh come to mind. Peterson is good, but really who else is out there? Saban will be gone soon, and I hope that the rebuild is complete by then. Not being a pumper, just trying to look at the glass half full. The OLine hopefully will be better next year. I'm a Trask fan (mostly to piss Law off), but if Franks is better, play him. If LDR plays, we're F'd. The offense needs to click next year, and if it does, it will be an entertaining year. Not sold on Mac, but we are a far cry from Muschamp. Unfortunately, we are a far cry from Bama too.