Cutcliffe won at Ole Miss when he had Eli Manning. When Eli left, Cutlcliffe promptly went 4-7. Ole Miss fired Cutcliffe because they were serious about wanting to go to the next level. They made a big mistake by hiring an SEC has-been Houston Nutt because Nutt had previous experience as the head coach at Arkansas.
Cutcliffe is a fine man and a knowledgeable, good football coach. He likes it at Duke. He is a good fit for Duke. Duke is not Florida. I know Spurrier was at Duke before he came to Gainesville, but Spurrier was on his way up, Cutcliffe is going to finish out at Duke then retire. Cutcliffe is old, looks old, and is a Phil Fulmer disciple where he was the right hand man to Fulmer and Peyton Manning's coach. We don't want Cutcliffe. Cutcliffe likes it at Duke. He is the right man for Duke at this time.
By the way, someone mentioned getting a committee to hire the next UF coach. Ole Miss went that route when they hired Hugh Freeze. Archie Manning headed the committee to hire Freeze who is turning out to be a home-run hire. But all coaching selections carry somewhat of a risk. I think we knew Urban Meyer was going to win here, and I think Alabama knew Nick Saban was going to win at Tuscaloosa. But those kind of slam dunk hires are not always available.
Also beware of committees in this day and age. You will get politically correct academic types that want to include a woman, or some ivory tower person who does not like football, or a student, and you know what I mean.