I'm really not trying to pick on you NV. You know we're boys. But this means absolutely nothing. You can only play the schedule that you have. We knew going into this year that the East was going to be garbage. Now I haven't looked at Bama's schedule but we have a lot of common opponents this year. And Bama by the eye test has the best defense in the nation.
I may be wrong, but I'm sure if you did this exact exercise with Bama's schedule you would have almost the same outcome. Maybe even worse for them because they played our offense.
Statistically, our defense got worse throughout the season as our offense completely tanked and could not hold onto the ball or score. In one of the last few games I think we had several starting defensive lineman out. I cannot find any statistics by quarter but I am sure that if you looked at the games by quarter breakdown you would see that our defense was stellar for about three quarters. Our offense at one point had not scored for something like 6 or 7 quarters.
The bowl game was an abject disaster on defense. I don't think that anybody is disputing that. It reminded me a lot of the games in 2007.
You're my favorite poster J and you know I love you but I'm not sure how you can say those stats mean absolutely nothing? Of course we can't help who we play, but our level of competition would have something to do with whether our Defense is considered Elite. If we played in the Mountain West and their teams schedules, and ranked 5th in the Nation, would you still consider our defense elite? No, you wouldn't and that would be because we didn't play anyone.
I agree that our defense gave up later in games and later in the year but the argument could also be that they simply wore down. It's what happens to defenses normally throughout games especially when they face a tough Running Back. And speaking of Running Backs, it's clear we struggled with the good ones because of our LB issue. Any team that had a decent RB we couldn't stop. Hell, Vandy's RB ran all over us and if Chubb would have been healthy I guarantee we would have lost that game. Once a QB got the courage to test VHIII, he got burnt many times. Sorry, but I don't think that's Elite.
To your question, here's Bama's Rankings. While they did play an FCS Team they still played a few tougher teams in the West like Arky and MSU.
Total Offense:
Wisky (72nd)
Mid. Tenn. (31st)
Ole Miss (22nd)
Louis. Mon. (115th)
Georgia (87th)
Arky (50th)
Texas A&M (47th)
Tenn. (66th)
LSU (55th)
Miss. St. (30th)
Charleston Southern (FCS)
Auburn (79th)
Florida (82nd)
Mich. St. (53rd)
Average: 61st
Offense Efficiency:
Wisky (50th)
Mid. Tenn. (48th)
Ole Miss (6th)
U. Lous. Mon. (124th)
Georgia (53rd)
Arky (1st)
Texas A&M (62nd)
Tenn. (22nd)
LSU (16th)
Miss. St. (15th)
Charleston Southern (FCS)
Auburn (40th)
Florida (71st)
Mich. St. (27th)
Average: 41st