CGator, since you and others have pointed out Shane and Danny as examples of less athletic passers who had success, let me point out that these guys played behind OLs that were far superior to the one we're trotting out this year. I think the guys who got blooded last year will improve and some of the new ones will prove to be good, but it's still a work in progress. LDR has got to have the time to get the ball where he knows it needs to go.
Furthermore, Shane and Danny were good at throwing guys open even with relatively weak arms. From what I've seen/heard, Trask(!) is the one who does that better than the others. Not saying Law's favorite should get the nod, but LDR can help himself and the O if he can start doing this more consistently.