After a 3 hr little league playoff game in 60deg rain, the family decided to have pizza-fireplace-movie_night to warm back up. I wanted the kids (daughter 11, son 8) to see some movies I saw growing up, so:
Herbie the Love Bug (1968):
I was worried I was losing everyone as the first 45-60 min did a lot of dialogue and character development before Herbie actually started showing up and expressing his personality. It got a little confusing when at the midpoint there is a bet made on a race and the winner gets Herbie, then we proceed to watch a dozen races where my kids ask every time "Is this the one for who gets Herbie?". I'll stop here and remind you all - this is a DISNEY film, from the late 60's, so my perspective has changed a lot since I've seen it. Now, I notice how thin the acting, dialogue, and storyline are. However, my kids are kids, and despite growing up with today's movies, they loved it. They were cheering at the end and were actually eager to watch the sequel, despite my asking for us to watch this one for nearly 8 months and everyone rolling eyes and groaning. Final verdict: 5/10, good for young kids and their first time seeing it. Otherwise, leave it on the shelf.
Herbie Rides Again (1974):
Told you the kids wanted the sequel, so that was next. Completely different cast, which I'd forgotten, but the kids couldn't tell and didn't care. Story was weaker, but still very Disney for that era. This time, the kids know Herbie and are following his every move, cheering along and fully appreciating his character - the others just kept the dialogue/plot moving, as weak as they were. Kids really loved the end when Herbie calls in for re-enforcements to hold off the bad guys. Final Verdict 4/10, only watch as a double feature - you'll never watch this on it's own, even with kids.
Personal notes - My wife had never seen these. She's asking if we can watch the re-make with Lindsey Lohan for the kids. I'm going to feign difficulty finding it until she drops the request. For me, not watching as a full accepting kid, but from behind eyes that have watched decades of movies (most of them bad), I saw a few different things. For example, there is a joust scene in a field, and yet the tires squeal like on pavement as they approach one another. Or, on another interior shot in the car (I'll give them credit for a lot of carryover from the original film) I see the radio was AM only. I mention this to my wife and ask if she noticed, only to have my son ask "Wait, they only get music in the mornings? What do they do in the afternoons?"