Julian Edelman was more concussed than Janay Rice

Jenny On The Railroad

Senior Member
Dunder;n165778 said:
There is zero doubt that NFL protocol requires him to be taken to the locker room for evaluation. Seattle was given a disadvantage with Avril, New England was allowed to skate. Did I mention he called Seattle "St Louis"????

agree that rules should be equally applied
 

Jenny On The Railroad

Senior Member
WobbleGator;n165773 said:
Edelman played great even after his so called "concussion".

That's irrelevant to the potential effects of concussion and irrelevant to the reasons for caution.

Nevertheless, I enjoyed watching him play- but that wasn't the point of OP.
 

WobbleGator

Chatterbox Mod
Jenny On The Railroad;n167357 said:
That's irrelevant to the potential effects of concussion and irrelevant to the reasons for caution.

Nevertheless, I enjoyed watching him play- but that wasn't the point of OP.

I know what the OP's point was and I disagreed with it.
 

Ray Finkle

Fallen Mod
Lifetime Member
Jenny On The Railroad;n167357 said:
That's irrelevant to the potential effects of concussion and irrelevant to the reasons for caution.

Nevertheless, I enjoyed watching him play- but that wasn't the point of OP.
:snob:
 

Gator98MD

Senior Member
Lifetime Member
more importantly is the negative societal/workplace effects Dunder's Avatar has, as Everytime he posts that thing, I want to concuss my jimmy
 

ppinesgator

aka "Biggums"
WobbleGator;n165813 said:
So physical performance has no relevance on whether he was concussed but you are using physical performance to say he was concussed? That makes sense.


Don't confuse an MD with facts, wobble.
 

Dunder

Member
Hey guys, sorry I've been out of touch. I've been on a whirlwind trip investigating this concussion matter. I've been to Glendale, Boston, New York, & Baltimore. I've interviewed the NFL head neurologist, the head referee, Edelman, Goodell & Janay Rice. It turns out that, in fact, Edelman was less concussed than Janay Rice. My bad.
 

GatorJ

Hopeful
Moderator
Dunder;172838 said:
Hey guys, sorry I've been out of touch. I've been on a whirlwind trip investigating this concussion matter. I've been to Glendale, Boston, New York, & Baltimore. I've interviewed the NFL head neurologist, the head referee, Edelman, Goodell & Janay Rice. It turns out that, in fact, Edelman was less concussed than Janay Rice. My bad.

Thanks for the research. When you get a minute, see if you can throw together a white paper for this board.
 

WobbleGator

Chatterbox Mod
Dunder;n172838 said:
Hey guys, sorry I've been out of touch. I've been on a whirlwind trip investigating this concussion matter. I've been to Glendale, Boston, New York, & Baltimore. I've interviewed the NFL head neurologist, the head referee, Edelman, Goodell & Janay Rice. It turns out that, in fact, Edelman was less concussed than Janay Rice. My bad.

You should have listened to me earlier. You would have saved yourself the money and time wasted on this research.
 

PastyStoole

Man, there's no boundary line to art. ~Bird Parker
Lifetime Member
Originally posted by Dunder View Post

There is zero doubt that NFL protocol requires him to be taken to the locker room for evaluation. Seattle was given a disadvantage with Avril, New England was allowed to skate. Did I mention he called Seattle "St Louis"????


WobbleGator;n165783 said:
I have heard plenty of people misspeak without ever taking a blow to the head. It happens, it doesn't prove that he was concussed.

I'm pretty sure Obama has had a concussion for the last seven years.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Help Users

You haven't joined any rooms.

    Forum statistics

    Threads
    31,747
    Messages
    1,628,864
    Members
    1,644
    Latest member
    TheFoodGator
    Top