If you have the time on your hands, and the wherewithal, I'd like to see that comparison. Would be good/valuable info.
I tend to agree w/ the aspects of this, but teams like Alabama, Ohio State, Clemson, UGA, LSU should only ever lose when they play one of the other teams. UGA losing to SC this year, Ohio State losing to Purdue last year, UF losing to Ole Miss in 2009 are big outliers. But it happens, it's college football.
I'm not ready to give up on Mullen by any means, and I do think we'll see a steady bump in our classes over the next few years. He just needs to get our classes inside the top 10, then shoot for the occasional top 5 class (once every 3 or 4 years?). I do think facilities will help, but that's a few years away.