I remember everybody on this board thinking the class last year was horrible and there was no way he would manage Top 10. The year before I remember people saying he got some good kids, but most people were bashing that he was not in the Top 10. The year before he did manage to scrounge together a class at the last minute....
You and I have very different memories, but I have never once thought we "won" the offseason. As far as signing these kids... Matty Ice is being pretty vocal so I think it is unlikely that he doesn't end up here. He is also on track to be an EE.
I think a lot of these kids want to play with him and will stay. We will lose some... everybody does, but I think most of what we have right now sticks and the staff had reason to celebrate. They had a fantastic Friday night lights... got a 5* QB who is already bringing in more talent.
Is there work to do? Of course? Do they need to have success when the games start... Yes... can we finally enjoy a week of good news without somebody dumping on it... apparently not on this board...
Again, youre memory is very one sided., the pumping over that second class was monumental. It wasn't a good class, but that didnt stop the mac brigade from posting quite a bit about how many diamond in the rough 3 stars we got b/c of how much better mac and co are at evaluating talent. And lots of effort to find the recruiting source who rated the class the highest. One place had us at 14 and that was pumped a lot, then compared to other individuals who later won something significant as if to say mac is equivalent to them.
There were plenty of people saying last years class was horrible, they were called dumpers. There were also plenty who said the same thing about the first class, and called the same as a result. But there was also a lot of pumping both years. I actually did a good bit of pumping the first class based on the situation, but the second class was inexcusable after the time he had to settle in, and the supposed great accomplishment of winning the east that pumpers claimed was very important and signficant. I was pleased with this class, and am very very pleased with the trend we are on right now for the 2018 class, but those kids aren't signed, and i would expect quite a few of them would jump ship quickly if we come out and look like another abortion on offense.
This fall's production on the field is what matters and is what will make these kids stick, not some pool or pizza party, and certainly not the tweets of a bunch of 17 year olds. Kids these days are as fickel and impressionable as ever; no loyalty and lots of games and trolling. Mark my words, we have another muschampion type 100+ offensive year and this recruiting class everyone is celebrating will be an epic bust. THAT is why some of us aren't doing cartwheels yet. Sorry if that bothers you.