Well in short, yes. He didn't average 8 wins because he couldn't even keep himself from a major gaffe in a press conference.
I also qualified it with averaging it over 3 years, winning 10 in year 3, and have said that off-the-field circumstances have to be considered. All things Dabo did. I'll repeat my point that if a guy puts up those records and doesn't embarrass the university with something away from football, he gets a 4th year. If you want to remove Mac as an "incomplete", that's fine. Zook and WM make my point. We may be a very demanding fan base, but we're not some outlier who routinely kicks competent coaches to the curb, which is what I took from your initial post. If I read it wrong, my apologies.